Jack Hayes departs Brown, leaving behind a changed athletics department and complicated legacy

Jack Hayes departs Brown, leaving behind a changed athletics department and complicated legacy

Join The Brown Day by day Usher in’s day by day publication to stick up to the moment with what is going on at Brown and on Faculty Hill regardless of the place you might be at the moment!


Like us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on Instagram

Email The Herald

Brown Daily Herald


  • Information
  • Sports activities

Little Rhody teaches little civics: Rhode Island scholars’ fight for a forgotten proper

Jack Hayes departs Brown, leaving at the back of a modified athletics division and sophisticated legacy

College will increase frequency of follow-u.s.for scholar checking out in spring semester

UCS, UFB kick off 2021 spring election season

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Information, Sports activities, College Information

Jack Hayes departs Brown, leaving at the back of a modified athletics division and sophisticated legacy

Reviews, reviews of athletics director’s tenure at Brown range broadly

As of January 29, 2021, Jack Hayes has made up our minds to step down as director of Brown Athletics. Colin Sullivan, deputy director of athletics, has taken the reins because the intervening time athletic director.

It have been a “attempting 12 months,” a student-athlete defined to The Usher in. That spring, a committee proposed slicing varsity sports activities groups to strengthen the athletics program’s competitiveness. A column in The Usher in, he added, had prompt that athletics had “no phase at Brown.” 

The 12 months in query was once now not 2020: it was once 2011, and the College was once in flux. The cuts by no means got here to fruition, however in iciness 2012, then-athletics director Michael Goldberger introduced his retirement, and a seek committee quickly introduced their select for the following athletics director: Jack Hayes. 

At an introductory press convention, the chief of the quest committee touted Hayes’ “management, revel in and dedication,” getting ready him for a task addressing fundraising objectives, facility enhancements and the student-athlete revel in. Hayes, on the similar press convention, promised to prioritize that have.

On Jan. 29, 2021, the College introduced that Hayes would step down. The athletics division, in some ways, seems to be other as of late — however the questions going through the dep. in 2021, which is grappling with a call to chop a lot of varsity groups and with the student-athlete revel in amid COVID-19, glance remarkably very similar to the ones posed in 2011.

Some athletes had been fast to reward Hayes’ tenure as athletic director; others noticed his time at Brown as a sequence of missteps. A couple of athletes depend him as a chum and a mentor; others discovered him an elusive determine who failed to interact key stakeholders. Many athletes had no opinion in any respect, possibly now not a wonder in a division that at one level integrated greater than 900 scholars in general. 

Leaving Brown, 9 years later

Faculty Hill was once Hayes’ newest forestall in a profession best possible described as an inventory of collegiate athletics departments: Windfall Faculty — as a lacrosse participant — then in management at Brown, Fairfield, St. John’s, Fordham, UConn, Hofstra and after all, at Brown once more. His subsequent task, as a senior guide on the sports activities challenge capital company Bruin Sports activities Capital, the place he has “recognized the folk for a very long time,” will likely be his first off-campus task.

“Jack is a phenomenal chief who understands the way to run a high-performing, values pushed group,” wrote George Pyne ’89, the CEO of Bruin Sports activities Capital, in an e mail to The Usher in. “The ones are exactly the forms of corporations we spend money on at Bruin, so we can glance to faucet into his many years of revel in and point of view.”

The aftermath of the Excellence in Brown Athletics Initiative, Hayes stated, performed a component in his resolution to go away, at the side of the “distinctive alternative” at Bruin Sports activities Capital.

“While you undergo one thing as difficult as ultimate spring was once, regardless that they made the fitting selections, there’s a time when new management and a recent point of view is most definitely a just right factor for an athletics division,” Hayes stated. 

“It’s truthful to mention it’s mutual,” he stated of the verdict.

Hayes’ have an effect on on athletics

Hayes stated he liked operating with scholar athletes, coaches and alumni right through his tenure. He pointed to a Ultimate 4 run for the lads’s lacrosse group in 2016, the ladies’s football group’s Ivy League championship in 2019 and classes of fulfillment for each swimming groups, volleyball, males’s basketball and ladies’s staff as highlights of his tenure. As athletics director, Hayes oversaw the creation of virtual platforms to look at athletics occasions and “$50 million price of amenities initiatives,” together with the development of recent stadiums and rehabilitation amenities.

“How those avid gamers expand has been immensely enhanced” by way of Hayes’ paintings, stated Head Soccer Trainer James Perry ’01. “I used to be an assistant right here in ’07 to ’09 — it’s a significantly better position to bodily, mentally expand avid gamers.”

The athletics division additionally constantly equipped enough investment for recruitment and making improvements to their groups’ standings, stated Perry and ladies’s football Head Trainer Kia McNeill.  

“2019 wasn’t one thing we constructed in a single day,” McNeill stated, relating to the group’s run to the NCAA match and Ivy League championship. With the exception of recruiting, McNeill stated the dep. performed a key position in sending the group to look at the 2019 FIFA Girls’s Global Cup in France and paying for the group to play Texas A&M in 2019.

The win in opposition to Texas A&M put the group at the nationwide radar, consistent with captain Sydney Cummings ’21. 

“Jack’s have an effect on is all over the place the athletic division and the College,” Pyne stated. “His legacy will cross on well past his tenure.”

Differing reviews on Hayes

However some athletes described a unique revel in, characterised by way of a seeming loss of passion from Hayes as he prioritized positive groups over others. In line with Zyana Thomas ’22, a ladies’s rugby participant, a congratulatory discuss with from Hayes after the group went via a duration of fulfillment “didn’t really feel like a honest congratulations.” 

“It felt like he didn’t in point of fact care, like we had been simply some other chore on his record,” she stated. Hayes didn’t spend “greater than 5 mins” with the group, she added. And when she earned a lot of accolades in ladies’s rugby, together with “making all-American,” Hayes despatched her a letter, she stated, with “not anything spelled appropriately,” her title integrated. 

“It gave the impression to me (Hayes) was once obsessive about lacrosse,” Thomas stated. “He put such a lot effort and time into lacrosse when there have been certainly different groups that deserved effort and time.”

Luke McCaleb ’21, a lacrosse participant and a former president of the Scholar-Athletics Advisory Committee, stated that Hayes was once “at all times there” for the lacrosse group — even attending group dinners once in a while.

McCaleb stated that Hayes at all times attended house video games, even appearing up in his personal jersey. “He was once a chum to the lacrosse program up to he was once in control of us.”

Each McCaleb and Tamenang Choh ’21, a males’s basketball participant, described seeing Hayes constantly at their video games, forging private relationships with Hayes’ circle of relatives, enjoying sports activities together with his children and in Choh’s case, even visiting his area for dinner.

For Maddie McCarthy ’23, a former member of the ski group who now runs for ladies’s monitor and pass nation, Hayes’ absence at ski group occasions — and seeming loss of attentiveness — proved extra noticeable.

She added that the ski group’s tools by no means gave the impression to display up on time. “We waited till November, December to get our group tools, and it was once spotted that each different males’s group in this campus had their tools first.” 

Hayes painted the dep.’s priorities as success-based — now not a “males’s as opposed to ladies’s” factor.

“When groups get started profitable and having fulfillment, there are stuff you begin to do for them to advertise and make their fulfillment visual, right through the campus (and) past the campus limitations,” he stated, bringing up the exposure the dep. created for ladies’s staff and football. 

Cummings, who were given to understand Hayes in my opinion over her time at Brown and now and then amassed skilled recommendation from him, stated, “I don’t assume Jack was once easiest, I believe it’s exhausting for an athletic administrator to be there each time.”

“Inevitably, you may have your favourite sports activities, you’re only a biased human,” she added. “On the similar time, he was once there for us.”

The Usher in reached out to 11 athletes, together with more than one that declined to talk in an interview at the foundation of getting no opinion of Hayes’ tenure.

“To this present day I nonetheless don’t in point of fact have an affiliation with him,” stated a feminine athlete who asked anonymity because of fears of repercussions from her trainer and the athletics division extra broadly. “I will have to.” 

Excellence in Athletics

Ultimate Would possibly, Hayes got here into the highlight with the Excellence in Athletics Initiative, which to start with aimed to reclassify 11 varsity groups as membership groups. Virtually right away, scholars and fogeys replied with campaigns and criminal movements to avoid wasting their groups. 

“I wouldn’t do it otherwise if we needed to do it once more,” Hayes stated. The initiative introduced “tricky selections, however they had been made in the most productive passion of long-term fulfillment of Brown athletics,” he added.

Critics of Hayes — or even some supporters — stated that they had been stuck off guard by way of the resolution itself and the College’s announcement, which got here in a sequence of emails and Zoom calls that presented athletes little time to react or recommend for themselves. 

The initiative “got here as a surprise to me. It was once a surprise to maximum coaches,” stated McNeill, who described herself as “dependable” to Hayes after he “took a possibility on her” by way of hiring her as a head trainer and helped information her via main a program for the primary time.

“The conversation was once tremendous surprising, tremendous premature,” Cummings stated. “I don’t assume they learn the room, I don’t assume it was once the fitting time.”

The verdict itself, McCarthy stated, was once much less problematic than the “atrocious” method the College went about making it and disseminating the scoop. A few of her coaches and athletics division staffers didn’t know in regards to the cuts till she instructed them.

“The hurt to the College and the criminal court cases, numerous that was once brought about as a result of (Hayes) was once sloppy and he blatantly confirmed he didn’t care about how he did it, how he was once making folks really feel,” McCarthy stated.

Hayes defended the rollout of the announcement, noting that the one approach to tell scholars previous would had been to alert them prior to any ultimate resolution was once made.

“You attempt to do it the fitting method … understanding that, in repeatedly throughout the procedure, the folk that you’re speaking with are upset and annoyed,” Hayes stated. “I sought after to make certain that they heard that data from me and that we performed no matter was once important to execute the selections that we made going ahead.”

Regardless of the preliminary affects of the initiative, Hayes proved receptive to a few advocacy: Lauren Reischer ’21, a member of the equestrian group, met with Hayes weekly ultimate summer time to recommend for the equestrian group after declaring that slicing it eradicated her slot because the College’s handiest athlete with a incapacity. Whilst a criminal agreement in the end restored the group’s varsity standing, it “in point of fact felt that we don’t have been reinstated with out Jack Hayes’ involvement over the summer time,” Reischer stated, going as a long way to explain him as an “best friend.”

The preliminary removal of the lads’s monitor and box and pass nation groups — whose rosters have consisted of a better share of racial illustration and socio-economic variety than the Brown scholar frame as a complete and different groups — additionally struck a nerve amid the Black Lives Subject protests that came about ultimate summer time prior to the groups had been reinstated.

“It felt in point of fact anti-Black,” Thomas, the ladies’s rugby participant, stated. “It didn’t make sense why you can minimize an overly a success group like that. At that time, I (idea), ‘I don’t care about you, I may just care much less about your insurance policies, I already know they aren’t going to profit me or my squad or any individual of colour.’”

Hayes was once in the end one of the folks concerned within the resolution — a bunch that integrated Company individuals, President Christina Paxson P’19 and out of doors advisors. Nonetheless, he was once some of the extra public-facing folks.

“I don’t assume (Hayes) had the general end-all say,” McCarthy stated. “The true resolution isn’t a call that may be made by way of one particular person by myself.”

Nonetheless, she stated, “should you’re going to indicate the finger at any individual, it needs to be at him.”

Having a look forward

The method of selecting a brand new athletics director has no set timeline, consistent with College spokesperson Brian Clark. Hayes’ variety took kind of two months in 2012.

“The timeline will likely be pushed by way of the quest procedure and the candidate pool it generates — a very powerful objective is to carry aboard the fitting chief for Brown Athletics,” Clark wrote in an e mail to The Usher in. 

Efforts to search out the following athletics director have already begun, Clark added. Within the interim, Colin Sullivan, deputy director of athletics, has taken the reins because the intervening time athletic director.

The following director will face a lot of demanding situations: an remarkable lawsuit filed by way of the squash groups, the lingering results of the pandemic, closing fallout from the Excellence Initiative and, following the Ivy League’s resolution to cancel the spring season, renewed discussions on particular remedy athletes may obtain if allowed to have interaction with avid gamers out of doors of the College.

Athletes expressed various hopes for the following director: McCaleb stated that he was hoping the following director can be “very similar to Jack Hayes” as a “chief” who is aware of athletes on a “private degree.” 

Reischer stated she prioritized a “responsive” director with the “imaginative and prescient” to make the Excellence Initiative a success. 

Thomas expressed hopes that the College would rent a girl of colour or an LGBTQ+ lady for the task who would prioritize making an investment in rising groups with out donor bases and lengthy histories. 

Cummings, the ladies’s football captain, echoed Thomas in her hopes {that a} lady of colour who may just “repair up the communications” and strengthen “transparency” would take the reins.

“I want my successor the most productive of good fortune,” Hayes stated. “I can be rooting for Brown athletics going ahead — I am hoping my successor sees numerous just right issues had been installed position, and I do know that my successor may have a possibility to paintings with nice coaches and an excellent body of workers.”